Sunlit Lexington-style living room with a linen sofa, oak coffee table and brick fireplace overlooking a quiet winter yard.

Comparing a New Build to a Resale Home in Lexington This Winter

"Does not account for sale concessions and/or downpayment assistance." That line sits in small type under the October 2026 market report for Lexington and Surrounding Areas, published by the Consolidated Multiple Listing Service, the MLS that covers the Columbia region. It is attached to two of the numbers buyers lean on most, the median sales price and the percent of list price received.

That footnote matters more than usual in the weeks before Thanksgiving. Several builders around Lexington are advertising their discounts in dollars, with deadlines. A resale home's discount, if it gets one, shows up in a closing credit, and the MLS headline figures don't count those. If you're weighing a new build off Calks Ferry Road against a ten-year-old house across town, the list price isn't the number to compare. Compare what each home costs after credits.

What Lexington's October report counts

The CMLS Local Market Update for Area 11, current as of November 10, 2026, shows homes in the Lexington area selling for 98.4% of list price in October 2026, up from 98.0% in October 2025. On a $315,000 home, that works out to about $5,000 below asking. Read alone, it looks like a market where sellers give up very little.

The other October figures suggest otherwise. Average days on market until sale rose to 56 in October 2026 from 44 a year earlier. Inventory reached 551 homes at the end of October, up 37.1% from 402. Closed sales for the month fell to 128 from 143. More homes are waiting longer for fewer buyers, and any closing credit a seller agrees to in that market stays outside the 98.4% figure.

The October median sales price of $344,038 was up 9.2% from a year earlier. The year-to-date median for January through October 2026 was $315,000, the same as for the same stretch of 2025. The report itself warns that percent changes can look extreme on small samples, and 128 sales is a small month. The flat $315,000 is the steadier read. Through ten months of 2026, Lexington prices held level while the number of homes for sale climbed.

What the builders are printing

Builders are saying out loud what the resale figures don't show. At Ferry Grove, D.R. Horton's community off Calks Ferry Road, more than 400 homesites are planned. Pricing starts at $250,000, and listed homes currently run from $282,500 to $326,790. The Ferry Grove page carries a Columbia Division promotion for up to $15,000 in flex cash and closing costs on select pre-sale homes. On a $282,500 home, $15,000 is about 5.3% of the price.

At South Lake Commons, the McGuinn Homes townhome community off I-20, available homes are priced from $223,990 to $237,000. The builder's holiday-season offer is savings of up to $12,000 or financing as low as 3.49%, 6.237% APR, on select homes through its lending partner. Twelve thousand dollars on a $223,990 townhome is about 5.4%. Mungo Homes announced in July 2026 that it had acquired McGuinn Homes.

Mungo's Lexington and West Columbia lineup includes Bluefield, priced from the high $200s to the high $300s, Hendrix Farms in the high $300s, and Hidden Springs in the low $300s. Stanley Martin's Summer Orchard has available homes from $282,940 to $354,900 and is selling its final section. Eastwood Homes' Ashton Lakes has homes from $309,900 to $354,975, including quick-move-in and under-construction homes.

Most of these homes are priced between about $225,000 and $355,000, the same range as Lexington's $315,000 median. The two advertised incentives come to roughly 5% of price. The October resale figure shows about 1.6% off list before concessions. A buyer comparing those two percentages is comparing a discount that has been published with one that hasn't, and the second may be larger than it looks.

The December 1 line at Ferry Grove

The D.R. Horton promotion has a firm date attached. It applies to new contracts on select pre-sale homes signed from August 19, 2026, through December 1, 2026, that close by December 31, 2026. December 1 is the Tuesday after Thanksgiving.

How the incentive is paid also matters when you compare it with a resale offer. Up to $5,000 can go toward options, upgrades, closing costs or price reductions with any lender. Up to an additional $10,000 goes toward closing costs if the buyer finances and closes with DHI Mortgage, D.R. Horton's affiliated lender. The terms state that buyers aren't required to finance through DHI Mortgage or another preferred lender to buy the home, but must use one to receive the closing-cost incentive. The full $15,000 depends on which lender you use. If you plan to use your own bank, the Ferry Grove figure to compare is $5,000.

McGuinn's offer at South Lake Commons is a choice of savings or a lower financing rate, and both run through its lending partner. Treat each of these offers as one possible structure and price it against the alternatives. A rate through a builder's lender can be weighed against a lower price paired with your own lender's rate, and your lender can run both numbers side by side.

Where resale sellers stand in the same price band

Across the whole CMLS region, the $250,001 to $350,000 price band is where Lexington's new construction and its median resale home overlap. That band had 1,441 homes for sale at the end of October 2026, up from 1,071 a year earlier, a 34.5% increase. Months of supply in the band rose to 3.7 from 2.8. Across all price ranges, regional months of supply reached 3.9, up from 2.8 in October 2025.

A Lexington homeowner listing a three- or four-bedroom house near $315,000 this winter is competing with more resale listings than a year ago and with builders printing five-figure credits on homes at nearly the same price. Those builder credits put a number on the competition a resale seller faces. That gives a resale buyer room to ask for something comparable: a seller credit toward closing costs, a repair allowance, or a price adjustment. If it's granted, it won't change the 98.4% that shows up in next month's report, because concessions aren't counted there.

Resale credits in Area 11 sit outside both headline figures. The October 2026 report does show the market they are negotiated in: 37.1% more inventory and twelve more days on market than a year earlier.

Comparing the two homes on one number

The comparison that holds up starts with each home's price after credits. From there, add the costs that come with each home. A new build at Summer Orchard or Ashton Lakes comes with a builder's choice of floor plans and lots, and with whatever finishes the incentive does or doesn't cover. A resale home in an established Lexington neighborhood comes with its own age, systems and yard. The headline numbers flatten all of this into one median and one percentage, and neither one includes the credit.

If you're early in your search, our guide to starting out in Lexington and the Lexington neighborhood page cover where these communities sit in daily life. The buyer resources cover the purchase process itself.

If you own in Lexington and plan to list

The same arithmetic applies from the seller's side. The buyers walking through your house this winter have probably already toured a model home where the sales office had a dollar figure printed on the page. Pricing at the October median and expecting 98.4% of list leaves out the credit many of those buyers will ask for. A home valuation built on recent sales near your street, plus a clear plan for how you'll respond to a credit request, puts your house on the same footing as the builder's. More on listing in this market is on our sellers page.

A few common questions

Does the 98.4% figure mean Lexington sellers are holding firm on price? It means October 2026 sales in Area 11 closed at an average of 98.4% of list price, with concessions and down payment assistance left out of the calculation. A sale with a $7,000 seller credit can still count as a full-price sale.

Is the October median jump to $344,038 a sign prices are rising fast? The year-to-date median through October 2026 is $315,000, unchanged from the same period in 2025, and the report itself cautions that monthly percent changes can swing on small samples.

What happens to the Ferry Grove incentive after December 1? The posted terms cover contracts signed through December 1, 2026, that close by December 31, 2026. The builder notes that pricing and terms can change at any time without notice, so ask the sales office what applies on the day you sign.

This post is general market information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm any financing or incentive terms with your lender and the builder before you rely on them.

If you're holding a builder's incentive sheet in one hand and a resale listing in the other, Phillip Jenkins and the Jenkins Group are glad to sit down with you and work out what each home costs after credits before the December 1 deadline. If you own in Lexington and are thinking about listing, request your free home valuation and we'll talk through how your house compares with the new homes nearby this winter.

Work With Phillip

Whether you're looking to sell your home or searching for your dream property, Phillip is here for you. Reach out to him today via phone or email to learn more about how he can put his experience and professional resources to work on your behalf. Don't hesitate to get in touch and start the conversation.

Follow Me on Instagram